josh  (11/1/2010 11:59:49 AM)

Yea seriously you people need help, SCI was fuckin awesome, ok i agree the second set was weak as shit do to poor song choices, but they still played them songs the best i have ever heard em and that is hard to do considering they werent good songs, but that just made the third set even better, comparing them to phish is just stupid considering they play two completly different styles of rock n roll, heres a thought for all you pessimistic losers that are downing cheese, go see phish and go on phish' site and say how great they are and leave sci tickets to people who enjoy good music and dont bitch online like little pussys. and who cares if your a phish vet, no one cares. Peace and love to all my FOC cant wait for the winter tour hopefully keller might add on in, and if we dont got a sci tour shit eoto is still tearing shit the fuck up. eat a hit download this show and stop bitchin, peace.

   lupo  (11/1/2010 11:32:09 AM)

hey,what is this?
a match between the two best jam bands ?
i am from germany and i never had the chance to see a concert of SCI
or Phish. but what i know is that both bands are great.
i have listened to about 120 shows of SCI and about 100 shows of Phish and
i think there no reason to say this band is better than the other.
i am greatful that both bands are alive and well.
and i hope that they know that there are a lot of people who wants to see them
one time,outside ihe USA.
you are great!

   Your Mom  (11/1/2010 11:19:17 AM)

Oh Lord. Looks like a couple of nasty trolls have stumbled over from that muck filled swamp called LivePhish. If you ignore them they will go away. They just need a hug or two and personally, I don't want to get my clothes dirty. Praise Cheesus:)

   Dawn L  (11/1/2010 11:08:19 AM)

Thank you for another AMAZING incident!!!!

? Much Love ?

   ulijon  (11/1/2010 10:44:46 AM)

Whats with all the negativity being posted? I am as big a Phish fan as anyone(since '93 and was at Hampton reunion and have seen 6 shows since then) and I was blown away at Hulaween. Both nights were amazing and anyone who was there will testify to this. Why does one have to be better than the other, just enjoy

   txkaje  (11/1/2010 9:52:46 AM)

I love when people compare bands. It's like comparing favorite colors. All I see when I read those comments is "Oh yeah green is WAY better than orange". Anyone arguing over what they like verses what other people like are just letting everyone know where they stand intellectually and socially. I pity those that have to make comments about what band is better. Wish them luck and growth. They need both. BTW, the shows were awesome. Any show in the space ship is awesome.

   Noah  (11/1/2010 7:02:21 AM)

Amazing show. I've loved SCI for many many years now and this was my first show, and what a first show it ended up being. Wasn't completely happy with the second set though. I feel that three sets should have had a few more "cheese classics", like Birdland and Missin' Me. ...Still not disappointed with the show - they jammed out with amazement. Gurth... sorry you're unhappy with the show but if you would have been there you would have had a second opinion, because being there live is something that no download or CD could ever compensate for. Again, amazing show and the Mothership is where it's at! Please come back to the east coast!

   Gurth  (11/1/2010 6:58:38 AM)

Deez- If you think that these are good shows, it's too bad you didn't see them even as recently as 2006, which was a year that they tore a hole in the universe.

These "Incidents" are reunion shows and the playing/tightness reflects that. Was at Hornings and the scene was kind and fun and I was so happy to be back with one of my favorite bands, but the shows were pedestrian when compared to the past. Good, not great.

Don't know what Phish you saw this year but the 7 I saw this year were smokin' and yes, I'm a Phish vet also. Since it seems obligatory... first show 4/9/93 @ State Theater in Minneapolis. Nanner, nanner!